Oct. 3, 2026

The Children’s Crusade 1212 – Part 2: Nicolas of Cologne

The Children’s Crusade 1212 – Part 2: Nicolas of Cologne
The Children’s Crusade 1212 – Part 2: Nicolas of Cologne
Conflicted: A History Podcast
The Children’s Crusade 1212 – Part 2: Nicolas of Cologne

After the humiliating rejection by King Phillip Augustus at Paris, the Children’s Crusade is forced to carry on without political support and find a different road to the Holy Land. Moving east into Germany, the Crusade amasses new followers, including a scrappy young boy named Nicolas from the shrine city of Cologne. But Pope Innocent III, the powerful head of the Catholic Church, is monitoring the Crusade closely from Rome, weighing his response to this unsanctioned movement…

SOURCES:

Asbridge, Thomas. The Crusades: The Authoritative History of the War for the Holy Land. Ecco, 2010.

Clayton, Joseph. Pope Innocent III and His Times. Bruce Publishing Company, 1913.

Cunningham, Hugh. The Invention of Childhood. BBC Books, 2006.

Gabriele, Matthew, and David M. Perry. The Bright Ages: A New History of Medieval Europe. Harper, 2021.

Gies, Frances, and Joseph Gies. Life in a Medieval City. Harper Perennial, 2010.

Gray, George Zabriskie. The Children's Crusade. Houghton Mifflin, 1870.

Hourly History. The Crusades: A History from Beginning to End. Hourly History, 2016.

Jones, Dan. Crusaders: The Epic History of the Wars for the Holy Lands. Viking, 2019.

Maalouf, Amin. The Crusades through Arab Eyes. Translated by Jon Rothschild, Schocken Books, 1984.

Nicolle, David. The Fourth Crusade 1202–04: The Betrayal of Byzantium. Illustrated by Christa Hook, Osprey Publishing, 2001.

Norwich, John Julius. Absolute Monarchs: A History of the Papacy. Random House, 2011.

Sayers, Jane. Innocent III: Leader of Europe, 1198–1216. Longman, 1994.

The Crusades. Captivating History, 2019.

Chronicles of the First Crusade. Edited by Christopher Tyerman, Penguin Classics.

Medieval Christianity. Captivating History, 2020.

Trow, M. J. The Children's Crusade. Pen & Sword History, 2008.

Hunnicutt, Wendell, editor. “Speech of Urban II at the Council of Clermont, November 26, 1095.” Reading List: Western Civilization, University of Texas at Arlington, https://websites.uta.edu/hunnicut/reading-list/readings-western-civilization/speech-of-urban-ii-at-the-council-of-clermont-november-26-1095/. Accessed 6 July 2026.

Farkel, William. “The Ebstorf Map: Unlocking Medieval Cartography and Its Hidden Meanings.” The Cartographic Institute, https://thecartographicinstitute.com/the-ebstorf-map-unlocking-medieval-cartography-and-its-hidden-meanings/. Accessed 6 July 2026.

“15 Medieval Jokes That Still Hold Up Today.” Medievalists.net, 23 May 2023, https://www.medievalists.net/2023/05/15-medieval-jokes/. Accessed 6 July 2026

Medievalists.net. (2024, April 17). How to be a shepherd in the Middle Ages. Medievalists.net

Lanigan, Dennis T. “The Departure – An Episode of the Child's Crusade, 12th Century, by Joanna Boyce Wells.” The Victorian Web, 22 July 2024, https://victorianweb.org/painting/wellsjb/paintings/5.html. Accessed 5 Aug. 2026.

This episode is sponsored by Rula. Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/conflicted #rulapod

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

==== INTRO ===== 

 

Hello and welcome to Conflicted, the history podcast where we talk about the struggles that shaped us, the tough questions that they pose, and why we should care about any of it.

 

Conflicted is a member of the Evergreen Podcasts Network; and as always, I’m your host, Zach Cornwell.

 

You are listening to the second and final episode of a two-part series on the Children’s Crusade of 1212. If you haven’t listened to Part 1 yet, I would definitely recommend listening to that first. We’ll be picking up the story right where we left off last time, and without a working familiarity with all the different threads we established in Part 1, the second leg of the journey might lose some of its impact. But of course, unlike a medieval peasant, you are free to do what you like. Listen backwards, forwards, or sideways. It’s entirely up to you.

 

Before we dive back into our story, however, I’d like to quickly recap the major beats of the previous episode, so we have all that context ringing clear as a church bell in our heads.

 

For as long as human beings have been scribbling down their history, one thing has remained the same. All great stories, especially the true ones, need to have a hero. And last episode, we met ours. But instead of an armored knight or a brave general or a courageous priest, our hero was a 12-year-old boy named Stephen. Stephen, or Etienne, as it would have been pronounced at the time, was a shepherd by trade and a dreamer by inclination. In his meadow outside the little French town of Cloyes, Stephen watched the clouds, tended his sheep, and tried to distract himself from the fact that he would likely die an old man in that very same meadow.

 

But then, one day, fate dropped a pebble into the clear, calm water of Stephen’s existence. By chance or divine intervention, the 12-year-old shepherd boy met a strange old pilgrim on the road outside of town. Words were exchanged, revelations were recieved, and that same afternoon, Stephen was sprinting back to the village convinced he had been visited by an avatar of Jesus Christ himself.

 

His eyes blazing with the conviction of genuine epiphany, Stephen told his fellow shepherd boys about his brush with the almighty. He told them that the strange pilgrim had given him letters written in angelic fire, addressed to the King of France, Phillip Augustus himself. His mission, Stephen explained to the wide-eyed shepherd boys, was to deliver these letters to the King, enlist his aid, and march all the way to the Holy Land to take back Jerusalem from the wicked Saracens. Rather than mocking him with the unique cruelty that only 12-year-old boys can deploy, Stephen’s friends actually believed him, and agreed to accompany him on his divine mission.

 

And there, in that little French town in the summer of 1212, the Children’s Crusade was born.

In a matter of weeks, thousands of people had rallied to Stephen’s cause.

 

Now why a spark that small would light a fire that big is still a matter of historical speculation, but it probably had something to do with the fact that every crusade since the first one in 1095 had been an abject failure – bloody parades of vanity, greed and strategic incompetence. Time and again, the landed nobility of Europe had demonstrated their inability to accomplish anything of lasting value in the Holy Land. Maybe, some thought, it was time for the blue bloods to make way for the new blood. As historian Jane Sayers writes:

 

The Children’s Crusade reflected the prevalent idea that simplicity and poverty might remedy all the Church’s ills. Where the politicians and leaders had failed, simple Christian people might triumph.”

 

Historian Antony Bridge elaborates:

 

Had not Christ said that the meek would inherit the earth? And had not that great soldier of Christ, St Paul, said that God’s strength was made perfect in weakness? Was it possible, therefore, that the former Crusades had failed because they had relied on the strong men of this world and not on the weak and the poor, who alone were filled with the authentic power of God? Such speculation fascinated a great many people, and created an atmosphere in which the extraordinary idea of a children’s Crusade could not only grow, but be taken seriously.

 

Whatever the exact nature of the social currents breathing life into Stephen’s movement, his story ignited some latent fervor in the peasant youth of France, and by the time the shepherd boy arrived on the outskirts of Paris, he was not alone. 30,000 people, most of them children or teenagers, amassed at the abbey of St. Denis, proclaiming Stephen of Cloyes the leader of a new and peaceful crusade that would retake the city of Jerusalem once and for all.

 

Unfortunately for Stephen and his flock, the political elite of France did not share their optimism. And they would not be spurred into action by a 12-year-old boy’s tale of strange pilgrims bearing letters from Heaven. King Phillip Augustus of France, an embittered old crusader himself, ordered the children to go home, do their chores, and forget all notions of marching on the Holy Land. As a contemporary source, a cleric from Laon wrote:

 

‘And so, this boyish revival was terminated as easily as it had begun. But it seemed to many, that by means of such innocents gathered of their own accord, the Lord would do something great and new upon the earth …’

 

Despite the wishes of King Phillip of France, the Children’s Crusade was far from over. With heavy hearts, the children realized that no French knights or Parisian men-at-arms would be joining them on their crusade, but the Lord works in mysterious ways, they assured each other, and perhaps the holy letters were simply a means to an end, a way to gather large numbers of the faithful under one banner.

 

In the Hollywood version of this story, if they ever make one, we might see Stephen of Cloyes dust off his robe, gather his flock – and after a short, but rousing speech – set off on the road to Jerusalem for a satisfying second act. But as we all know, Hollywood is not history, and it is at this point in the story that the primary sources guide us directly into a narrative brick wall.

 

After the dramatic gathering in Paris / In the aftermath of the dramatic showdown with King Phillip Augustus – which may or may not have even taken place - the story of the Children’s Crusade suddenly presents us with a protagonist problem:

 

In late summer of 1212 AD, Stephen of Cloyes, our hero on the rise, suddenly vanishes without a trace. This charismatic shepherd boy who started the movement, whose message managed to compel 30,000 people to toss aside their daily responsibilities and march off towards mortal danger, just disappears from the history books. To this day, his ultimate fate is a mystery. No one knows what happened to him or where he went, or why.

 

We can speculate, of course. Maybe, disillusioned and humiliated by King Phillip’s dismissal, Stephen returned back home, crestfallen, to his sheep. Maybe the King had him quietly disposed of in an effort to deprive this people’s crusade of its oxygen. Or maybe Stephen remained with the movement but was eclipsed by older, more experienced boys. And more imaginative and devout storytellers might suggest that he was called back home to Heaven in a shimmer of light. The fact is, we just don’t know. As Gary Dickson writes:

 

“All we know is that Stephen, the holy shepherd boy from Cloyes, disappears from the record at this stage. His place centre stage in the story of the Children’s Crusade lasted for a little less than two months.”

 

This is, of course, very unsatisfying. Heroes do not often disappear from their own story halfway through. Imagine Frodo Baggins, midway to Mordor, suddenly dropping the Ring in Samwise Gamgee’s hand and wandering off into the forest, never to be heard from again. Imagine Luke Skywalker, fresh off his victory at the Death Star, telling Han and Leia that he’s leaving the rebellion to pursue a career in interior decorating / as a DJ. Imagine John McClane, after killing the first terrorist in Nakatomi Plaza, deciding to call an Uber and leave the hostages to their fate.

 

When you read about the unceremonious exit of Stephen of Cloyes from the primary sources, you can almost hear thousands of frustrated historians grinding their teeth in unison. Where did he go? Why did he leave? And more importantly, who stepped into that five-foot vacuum and galvanized the children to continue their journey, rather than disband altogether?

 

Well, as the Children’s Crusade drifted east across central Europe, a new figure rose to replace Stephen of Cloyes, and it was he who would ultimately see the pilgrimage to its sad conclusion, a mysterious boy named Nicolas of Cologne.

 

During that strange summer of 1212 AD, there were many watchful eyes following the progression of the crusade, and even at the time, it was incredibly controversial. As M.J. Trow writes:

 

“For every adult who viewed the Children’s Crusade as a remarkable act of piety and who felt sorry for the Children, there was another who found their behavior objectionable and their presence, in their particular backyard, as unwarrantable.”

 

[…] It was left to individual consciences whether people gave food, clothing and shelter to the Children or whether they threw stones at them and drove them out of their immediate locality. The balance of probabilities is that most people treated them with kindness, if only to get rid of them.”

 

But watching the movement with particular interest, was the city of Rome – the seat of the Papacy and the heart of Latin Christendom. These days, most people get a little nervous when the Catholic Church takes an interest in small children, but in the summer of 1212 AD, their intentions were a little more Innocent. PopeInnocent, to be precise. Last episode, we briefly encountered the Holy Father and Vicar of Christ himself, an energetic and deeply ambitious man named Lothar of Segni – although history remembers him simple as Pope Innocent III. He was, writes historian Joseph Clayton, “the youngest man ever elected pope.”

 

From his throne in Rome, Innocent monitored the Children’s Crusade with growing unease. For years, the Pope had envisioned an official crusade that would be able to rectify the mistakes of the past, dislodge the Saracens from Jerusalem, and reestablish Christian dominion over the Levant. In his private moments, he must have imagined walking through the streets of the Sacred City, surrounded by roaring crowds and blaring trumpets, placing his pale hands on the stone of the Holy Sepulcher – something no Pontiff in the history of the Church had done.

 

It was a vision that could only be accomplished through a crusade.

But this, [what was happening in France] was not what he had in mind.

 

As the Children’s Crusade grew in size and moved eastward, gathering momentum, strength, and followers, the time would come when Innocent would have to make a decision. Would he embrace these pint-sized crusaders? Would he incorporate them into his agenda and bestow his blessing upon them? Or would he reject them and brand them as misguided little fools.

 

Only time would tell.

 

So, with that preamble out of the way, we can jump back into the story and find out what happens when tens of thousands of adolescent religious fundamentalists march across one of the most populated regions in the world.

 

Welcome to The Children’s Crusade of 1212 – Part Two: Nicolas of Cologne.

 

 

==== BEGIN =====

 

It’s July of 1212 A.D.

 

About two months after the Children’s Crusade first sprang into existence in a little meadow outside the village of Cloyes. But today, we are about as far as one can get from a picturesque little hamlet in the French countryside. We are 300 miles to the northeast, in the merchant city of Cologne.

 

That’s C-O-L-O-G-N-E – Cologne.

 

THE BIG CITY

 

Hundreds of years before the invention of an alcohol-based personal fragrance put it on the map in 1709, the city of Cologne was a sprawling, brawling, caterwauling hotbed of commerce and enterprise. The kind of town where fortunes are made [and dreams] are broken in the same evening - and often at the same gambling table. Looming over the muddy banks of the famous Rhine River, the metropolis of Cologne is basically the medieval equivalent of Chicago or Detroit.

 

On the bustling riverside docks, where ships from all over the world unload their precious cargo, you’ll hear voices shouting in Italian, cursing in Spanish, and praying in Russian. You might hear a bit of news from Constantinople, or a joke from London. But mostly you’ll just hear: Get the hell out of my way. Yes, in the tiny French village of Cloyes, everybody knows your name. In the city Cologne, you’re lucky if anyone cares what your name is.

 

Flash photography did not exist in the 13th century, but if it did, visitors to the city would’ve been snapping pictures every 10 feet. Look over there, at the stone walls built by the Romans of old! Look over here at the towering cathedral! Look over there at…yet another towering cathedral. In medieval cities, conventional wisdom held that you could never have too many churches, and Cologne had one on just about corner.

 

It was the same urban planning philosophy behind public restrooms. The more the better, because frankly, you never know when you might need one. Yes, in a big city like Cologne, with so much humanity clumping and bumping together, there was a deadly sin lurking in every alcove, and cooing from every brothel; and being able to pop into a local church like a 7-Eleven for a quick fix of forgiveness/absolution was not only convenient, it was a daily necessity.  

 

And one of these poor sinners, trudging through the rainy streets of Cologne, is a young man named Nicolas. Now when I say “young man”, I’m using the medieval definition of the term, which would put Nicolas at the ripe old age of 14/15 years old. Nick may have acne on his cheeks and a relatively recent appreciation for the opposite sex, but in the eyes of the law, the church, and society in general, he is a grown-ass man. As MJ Trow observes:

 

“In the twenty-first century, we keep our children as children for far longer than at any time in the past.”

 

Like all medieval German boys his age - prefrontal cortex be damned - Nicolas can go to war, or be held legally responsible for a crime. He can father children, open a business, apply for membership in a trade guild. All the prudent and practical pursuits of the adult world.

 

But Nicolas has no interest in doing any of those things.

 

There were some people, recently relieved of their valuables, who might call Nicholas a thief or a pickpocket/cutpurse. But he prefers the term “urban entrepreneur”. For a poor boy of humble birth like Nick, surviving on the mean streets of Cologne requires a more… flexible code of ethics. “Thou shall not steal”, said the 8th commandment; but it didn’t say anything about “Thou shall not pick a lock” or “Thou shall not take an apple when the grocer’s not looking.”

 

There had been a time, of course, when Nick had more upstanding aspirations. Like Stephen of Cloyes, Nicolas was a shepherd’s son. Like Stephen, Nicolas had grown up learning how to feed a lamb, sheer a ewe, and calm a ram. But unlike Stephen of Cloyes, who found that sort of thing gratifying, Nicolas of Cologne had no interest in chasing after lost sheep. At some point in his young life, he hung up his shepherd’s staff, ran away from home, and made his way to the big city. Before long, he was the one being chased.

 

But honestly, Nick doesn’t mind the life of a vagabond. He likes living in Cologne. It certainly beats shoveling shit back at his father’s farm. Through a mix of legal and extralegal activity, he scrapes by as best he can. All he has to do is keep one step ahead of the law, his landlord, and the local clergy.

 

And as Nick walks the streets of Cologne, looking for his next mark, he catches the eye of a shop guard, essentially a private police officer.

 

For a professional thief, it’s very important to be familiar with faces before they are familiar with you, and this particular guard may or may not have chased Nicolas down an alley once or twice on a moonlit night. Not wanting to risk recognition and an unhappy reunion, Nick wisely takes a hard right off the main road and ducks into a back alley.

 

Like most medieval cities, Cologne is a very claustrophobic place. Off the main thoroughfare, the walls of houses and guild halls literally sag and lean against eachother like old drunks, creating tight, angular alleyways. It may be cramped, and it may smell like an outhouse, but at least it’s quiet. / But it’s quiet.

 

Or at least it was quiet.

 

THE STREET FIGHT

 

Nick’s ears prick up and identify a strange noise coming from around the corner. It almost sounds like an animal whimpering or a child crying. Ignoring his instincts to avoid investigating strange noises in dark alleyways, Nick proceeds deeper into the gloom.

 

Around the corner, he sees three large teenagers – older and considerably larger than Nick. And cowering at their feet, trembling in the mud, is a little boy, barely more than 7 or 8 years old. The big teenagers are taunting the little boy, pushing him, pinching him, emptying his pockets and spitting on his clothes. The little boy is crying in a different language, one that Nick recognizes as French. He also notices that the little boy has a small red cross stitched onto his tunic.

 

Interesting, Nick thinks, a pilgrim. In the last few days, Nick had seen crosses just like it all over Cologne. A large group of French pilgrims had recently arrived in the city, begging for alms and soliciting donations. The bailiffs had driven most of them outside the walls, of course, not wanting their streets overrun with homeless zealots, but some stragglers remained. Stragglers like this scared little boy, easy prey for local thieves who were eager to relieve the pilgrims of donations they had received.

 

Watching from the dark, Nick feels an anger rising in his chest. You can steal from millers, you can steal from tailors, you can even steal from tanners – if you can hold your breath long enough. But you don’t steal from little kids. First of all, there’s no sport in it. Second of all, kids rarely have anything of value. But to these cruel teenagers, defenseless little boys hold a certain entertainment value, and tormenting this one will be the highlight of their day.

 

Now, teenagers generally fall into three categories. Bullies. Victims. And the ones who look away and pretend not to see anything. Nicolas of Cologne is none of the above.

 

“Hey,” Nick says, stepping out of the shadows, “Leave him alone.”

 

The three teenagers turn in Nick’s direction, and their hard eyes settle on him. Nick points a finger at the red cross stitched on the little boy’s tunic. “Lay off, guys. He’s a beggar. A pilgrim. Probably got nothin’ on him except prayers and lent. Waste of your time, if you ask me. Just let him be.”

 

Knuckles crack in the heavy silence, (as if to say “no one asked you”) and the teenagers advance on Nick with violent intention. The French pilgrim, thankful that he is no longer the center of the bullies’ attention, wipes blood from his nose and skitters away.

 

Now, Nick was a seasoned veteran of many street fights– he’d even won a few on occasion. But this was not one of those fights. A few minutes later, after the older boys have finished tenderizing his face and putting spiderweb cracks into his skull, they walk away laughing, but not before giving him one final kick in the ribs for good measure. Lying in the gutter, groaning with regret, Nick hears a little voice above him.

 

“Merci”

 

Nick looks up and sees the little French kid, smiling gratefully. “De rien”/ “Pas de quoi”, he replies, touching his head and coming away with bloody fingers.

 

Suddenly, the little boy starts speaking very fast. Nick knows some French; not much, but enough.  In the torrent of speech, he hears words like “campsite” and “pilgrimage” and “Jerusalem”. He hears names like “King Phillip” and “Stephen”. None of it means much to him, but one word in particular catches his ear. “Food,” the little boy says, “Would you like some food?”

 

That evening, around a campfire outside the city, Nick gnaws on a hunk of stale bread. “I thought you said you had food,” he mutters.

 

In his 14/15 years of life, Nick has seen a lot of strange things. He’s seen Byzantine traders with silver teeth. He’s seen fiery objects streak across the night sky. He’s even seen a priest sneak through the back door of a brothel.  But one thing he’s never seen, is an entire countryside filled with religious pilgrims.

 

For miles and miles, the campfires stretch, flickering along the banks of the Rhine. This massive procession, Nick is told by children tugging at his shirt – this strange roadshow of peasants, serfs, and little kids – is heading for Jerusalem.

 

Like any medieval teenager, Nick knew about Jerusalem, but he didn’t know why anyone in their right mind would want to go there. Powerful kings and huge armies had attempted to reclaim the Holy City, and yet they had all failed. What chance did this kindergarten on wheels have against the Saracens? As if to underscore this point, across the campfire, Nick sees a little girl with a red cross on her dress stick a finger up her own nose, and start digging for treasure.

 

Crusaders, my ass, he thinks.

 

Curled up by the campfire, still bleeding heavily from his scalp, Nick slips beneath the surface of a deep and impenetrable sleep.

 

INNOCENT’S PRAYER

 

700 miles to the south, in the Italian city of Rome, an old acquaintance of ours is having a much harder time falling asleep.

 

Deep within the Papal palace, past the iron gates and armored sentries and the endless labyrinth of chambers, alcoves and anterooms, the Holy Father is saying his nightly prayers.

 

When you are the Pope - the leader of an entire religion - you don’t get much time to yourself. From the moment you wake up, to the moment you go to bed, your day is filled with endless, incessant activity. Cardinals complaining, bishops braying, priests pontificating. So many people, demanding so many things. But during this time, in the privacy of his bedchamber – these moments are his and his alone. All day long, he is “Pope Innocent III”, but for a few precious minutes before bed, stripped of his Papal vestments, he can be Lothar again.

 

Kneeling beneath a solid gold crucifix, Pope Innocent clasps his hands together and makes contact with the home office. If Christianity is a corporation, Innocent is its CEO. But every CEO is beholden to a board of directors; and in this case, the figures sitting around the metaphysical conference table are the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. And unfortunately, Christendom has had a very, very bad quarter. A bad quarter century, more like it.

 

What do Popes pray for? Ask them to their face and they’ll tell you things like “peace on earth” or “good will towards men”, but in reality, their heavenly wish list is probably a little more pragmatic.

 

Please God, Innocent murmurs in the cavern/cathedral of his mind, make King John of England stop being such a defiant prick and submit to my commands. Please God, let the German princes break out in hives, kill each other and save me the trouble of mediating between them. Please God, let the Benedictines and the Cistercians and all the other monastic orders toe the line and stop causing trouble.

 

But most of all, God, please tell me what to do about these kids.

 

In recent weeks, news had traveled fast from the court of King Phillip, and by the time the Children’s Crusade assembled at St. Denis in June of 1212 AD, Pope Innocent was well-appraised of the situation.

 

For the Pontiff, the term “crusade” brought up bad memories. Old failures that stung like welts to the touch. For Innocent, the word “crusade” was synonymous with defeat, venality, and humiliation. Going back more than 100 years, his Papal predecessors had been calling crusades to take back the holy land. Pope Urban had called the First. Eugenius had called the Second. Gregory had called the Third. Each one had been a disaster in the making, or a disaster on a time delay.

 

But then in 1198, the very same year he was elected Pope, Innocent called the Fourth Crusade, thinking that this time, things would be different. With his new and dynamic leadership, the Holy Land would finally come back into Christian hands. But in the months to come, as outraged letters and panicked messengers flooded into the Papal palace, Innocent learned that his crusade had imploded too, just like all the others.

 

Not only did the Fourth Crusade fail to retake the Holy Land, it failed to even reach the Holy Land. After raiding and pillaging its way down the Adriatic coast, the crusader army turned its eyes on the wealthy Byzantine capital of Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul). By the spring of 1204, the crusaders had attacked the city, looted it of all its treasure and installed themselves as the new kings of Byzantium. To his horror, Pope Innocent realized that he had launched a crusade whose only accomplishment was sacking the greatest Christian city in Eastern Europe.

 

8 years later, in 1212 AD, the shame of the Fourth Crusade was still raw and red as a fresh sunburn, and Innocent was looking for opportunities to rectify the past - to regain God’s favor and strengthen the diminished prestige of the Church.

 

Innocent knew all too well that Crusades don’t just fail by accident. Oh, you can blame all kinds of factors and variables – the soldiers, the weather, battlefield conditions. But everyone knows that at the end of the day, God is the one who decides whether Crusades succeed or fail. And for some unknowable, maddening reason, the Almighty had not seen fit to bless them with any kind of lasting victory. It was enough to make you wonder if God was listening at all.

 

Clutching his rosary with white-knuckle pressure, Innocent prays for an answer. What is the problem? Why do we keep failing? Why, God, do you keep allowing these heathens to defeat us again and again and again? What are we doing wrong? What am I doing wrong? Peering down at Innocent from the golden crucifix, Christ’s tiny metallic face is unreadable, as if to say: “Wouldn’t you like to know?”

 

 

Belief wasn’t the issue, that’s for sure. It wasn’t as if raw faith was not in short supply. Everyone believed. In the 21st century, religion is a personal choice. In the Middle Ages, religion was a choice in the same way that breathing is a choice. You don’t have to do it, but eventually, there will be consequences.

 

Desperate for some sign, some form of guidance, the Pope’s thoughts turn to other problems, specifically the recent events in France and Germany; and the so-called “Children’s Crusade.” Except it’s not a crusade, Innocent thinks. By definition, a crusade can only be called by the Pope. By me! Anything else is unauthorized, unsanctioned, effectively illegal in the eyes of the Church.

 

It’s not that the kids were heretics. They didn’t harbor some deviant view of the faith like the Cathars or the Waldensians. Frankly, it would have been easier if they were heretics. Then he could declare them enemies of the Church and command the local lords to round them, chop them up, and burn them up. Problem solved. But there was nothing technically heretical about these children at all; they weren’t a counter-cultural movement or a mouthpiece for systemic change. They were just enthusiastic volunteers, with theological views that were in lock-step with traditional Christendom.

 

But that didn’t mean they weren’t a problem. The Children’s Crusade was a distraction, a disruption, a drain on resources. And worst of all, they had no chance of success.

 

This mobile daycare had no soldiers, no weapons, no military support of any kind. Even if these 30,000 children somehow managed to march across Europe, through the Balkans, and beyond Constantinople, they’d be massacred before they got within 500 miles of Jerusalem. Generations of the best knights in Europe had been slaughtered in the Holy Land – what chance did a few thousand kids have?

 

There was a small part of Innocent that sort of admired them. It was hard not to – facing impossible odds while the lords of Europe squabbled over titles and territory. As the Pope commented at the time.  “the very children shame us, for they rush to the recovery of the Holy Land while we sleep.”

 

Pope Innocent had hoped that King Phillip of France would be able to scatter the children and send them back home to their parents where they belonged. But instead, the kids had just packed up their tents and moved on. Even the strange disappearance of their leader, the shepherd boy Stephen of Cloyes, had done nothing to soften their determination. They just kept marching.

> 

The quickest, most direct path to Jerusalem would’ve been to head south from Paris down to the port of Marseilles, where they could board ships that would take them to Sicily, then to the Holy Land. At least that’s what a conventional, well-funded crusader army would have done. But the children’s crusade was anything but conventional, and it certainly was not well-funded.

 

Unsupported by King Phillip, but unwilling to abandon their mission, the crusader children drifted east in search of more sympathetic adults. The abbey of St. Denis, with its cornucopia of religious relics, had proven to be a dead end. But it was not the only shrine city in northern France, or Europe for that matter. It was not the only place where good-hearted people might toss a few coins into the bowls of pilgrims bound for the Holy Land.

 

And so, they hit the road. Traveling northeast along the pilgrim’s trail, the Children’s Crusade embarked upon a cross-country tour of all the major religious shrines. As Gary Dickson writes:

 

“For whatever reason—or impulse—their road “to the sea” directed them to the Rhineland. […] Dotted along their route were shrine-cities—Chartres; Saint-Denis; Aachen; way stations on the long, hard road to Jerusalem, which was Christendom’s incomparable shrine-city.”

 

And as they went, their numbers swelled. Not just with children, but adults too. Peasants who were eager for a change from their monotonous, backbreaking existence. As Dickson continues:

 

“Perhaps 85–90 percent or more of the people who lived in thirteenth-century Europe were peasants; regional estimates vary. On the Children’s Crusade, the proportion of peasants may have been higher still. Medieval Europe had water power, wind power, and horse and oxen power, but its main source of energy remained peasant sweat. All of Latin Christendom’s towering Gothic super-structure rested on the stooped backs of peasant laborers.”

 

[…] So the chance to exchange an imposed social identity saturated with belittlement and negativity, one inviting self-hate, for a new identity, freely-chosen, conferring prestige and quasi-chivalric status—that of a crusader—would have proved irresistible. Hence for these peasant pueri, going off on crusade implied something more than a voyage to God and Jerusalem. It was an opportunity to escape from vilification and exploitation, a means of running away from a selfhood brutally imagined by others.”

 

As the Crusade crossed into Germany and more and more peasants joined its ranks, the demography of the movement began to broaden and change. This crusade was not just for children anymore. According to Dickson:

 

“The revival in the Rhineland became more heterogeneous, with urban workers, older people, mothers, babies, perhaps entire families joining it. While retaining its name and character as a youth movement, it was now a full-fledged popular crusade.”

 

Ultimately the procession found its way to the greatest shrine city in Northern Germany, the adopted home of our new friend Nicolas, the one and only Cologne.

 

“By 1212 Cologne had become the largest and wealthiest of the medieval German cities,” explains Dickson, “Port and emporium both benefitted from the growth of trade, especially from the East. […] On the Christian map, Cologne was one of the four major pilgrimage destinations in medieval Europe, along with Santiago and its cult of St. James; Canterbury, the locus of the martyred St. Thomas Becket; and Rome, hallowed by St. Peter and St. Paul. Cologne owed its place in this privileged foursome by virtue of its claim to possess the relics of the Three Kings, the Magi, the bringers of gifts from the exotic East to the crib of the infant Jesus.”

 

Yes, in its own way, Cologne was a holy city unto itself, which would explain why the Children’s Crusade had found its way there. But they certainly wouldn’t’ stay there long. For a week or two, the pilgrims would beg for alms, pray at the bones of the Magi and gather new recruits, but then they would turn south – marching over the Alps and through northern Italy toward the next stop on their itinerary, Rome itself.

 

As he prays beneath the impassive golden crucifix, the thought of 30,000 unwashed pilgrims flooding the streets of Rome makes Pope Innocent’s lip curl involuntarily. He had spent years bringing order and legitimacy to a Papacy in crisis. He had canonized, codified and consolidated. He mediated imperial successions, extorted kings, and placed entire nations under threat of excommunication. He was, in the eyes of many, the most powerful man on earth.

 

But these pilgrims - these kids - threatened to upset the delicate balance he was trying to maintain. And the longer they were allowed to run amok, the longer they were allowed to create chaos and upheaval across Europe, the longer it would take to mobilize the nobility’s appetite for a real, militarily viable crusade. AS Gary Dickson writes:

 

 Popular Christianity was vibrant, sometimes distressingly so. It was there to be regulated, curbed, channeled, encouraged—and, if necessary, strangled at birth.

 

Yanking the silk sheets over his shoulders, Innocent settles into bed, anticipating yet another sleepless night. After taking one last look at the bored expression of the golden crucifix, Innocent scowls, and with an angry puff of air, blows out the candle.

 

==== MUSIC BREAK =====  (12 pages in)

 

NICK’S DREAM

 

We’re on a beach.

 

Standing at the shoreline with wet sand between our toes. Waves are crashing, seagulls are cackling and the wind is whistling.

 

When most people hear the word “beach”, they picture tropical white sand and little drinks with pink umbrellas. Others might picture/imagine/envision pebbly coves, tall evergreens, and fishermen with heavy coats, hunched over their poles.

 

But this beach is different. It’s deserted, for starters. There are no people, no houses, not even a scrap of driftwood. Just miles and miles of flat, undisturbed sand – pure as virgin marble. And yet, this beach is not completely empty. Standing alone at the waterline, Nicolas of Cologne feels the cold waves rushing over the tops of his feet and lapping at his ankles. / the sand sucking at his heels.

 

Strangely, he has no memory of coming to this beach. In fact, he’s never seen a beach before in his life. He turns his head to look behind him and sees no footprints in the sand, no evidence whatsoever of his arrival here. And yet, he doesn’t feel scared or confused or overwhelmed. He feels calm and confident. Like he’s right where he needs to be.

 

Suddenly, Nick feels something in the palm of his right hand. He looks down and sees that he is holding some kind of long wooden rod. It could easily be mistaken for a shepherd’s staff, if not for the cap of burnished iron fixed to the top, forged into the shape of a “t”.  Later, Nick will learn that this is the Greek letter “tau”, a powerful protective symbol in Judao-Christian iconography. But right now, on this empty beach, he doesn’t question it at all.

 

Grasping the wooden staff in both hands, Nick allows the point of its base to sink into the soft sand, letting the weight of iron tau do the work. And then, something odd starts to happen. The grains of sand around the staff begin to jump and ripple and vibrate. Little crabs and sandworms burrow frantically out of the sand, scuttling away to escape the tremors.

 

And then, as if pushed apart by a pair of invisible hands, the sand at Nick’s feet separates, creating a trench that gets wider and deeper in a matter of seconds. The trench leaps out towards the water, beneath the waves and into the sea.

 

Craning his neck upward, Nick watches as the ocean itself begins to part and rise into the air, sending up massive walls of water on either side – liquid/twin cliffs higher than the tallest cathedrals in Cologne. And between the walls of water, extending hundreds of miles into the distance, is a narrow corridor of dry sand, straight as an arrow. And at the end of that corridor, across the sea, Nick sees a city, winking in the light. He’s never been there, he’s never seen it before, but in his heart, he knows its name. He's known its name his whole life:

 

Jerusalem.

 

Then, without warning, Nick’s ears are assaulted by a deafening noise. An incomprehensible roar of sound and music, like ten thousand war trumpets blaring straight into his ear drums. Dropping to his knees in excruciating terror, he looks up into the air and sees a mass of flame and eyes and terrible geometry. Something that should not exist, but exists nonetheless. It is an angel, he realizes. Not the two-dimensional cherubs with pink cheeks and pigeon wings that adorn the walls of churches, but a real angel. A seraphim of the Old Testament. The smiting kind. The kind that levelled cities and wiped out populations.

 

For Nick, kneeling in the sand, the heat of it is unbearable. He feels as if he is chained to a stake six inches from a bonfire, and yet, he cannot run away. He cannot even move. The sand is bubbling at his feet, superheated into a liquified froth.

 

The angel hovers there for just a moment, burning, smoldering in mid-air, dozens of eyes blinking at irregular intervals, its six wings hissing and evaporating sea spray on contact, and then, without so much as a parting word, it shoots down the sand corridor like a molten bullet, disappearing into the distance, and leaving a trail of smooth glass cooling in its wake. As the heat recedes, Nick hears a voice in his head. Just three words.

 

“To the sea”, it says.

 

And then, he wakes up.

 

> 

NICK THE LEADER

 

With a gasp and a spasmic kick of his feet, Nicolas of Cologne lurches back into the waking world. His eyes blink, his head swivels, and as the fog of the dream clears, he sees that there is no water, there is no ocean, there is no staff, and definitely no angel. He is curled up next to a dead fire in a crusader camp outside Cologne.

 

It’s impossible to say where religious experiences come from exactly. They usually happen – conveniently – in isolation. Moses and the burning bush. Mohammed and the angel in the cave. Paul on the road to Damascus. Encounters in the wilderness with zero witnesses. But that doesn’t mean that the people who have these experiences don’t believe them with absolute sincerity. It is real to them. And the universal factor, the common emotional thread, seems to be some indescribable mixture of fear and awe. A divine horror that changes you forever.

 

And when he woke up from his dream outside the city of Cologne, Nicolas had indeed changed. Or at least that’s what people said in the weeks and months to come. When Nick fell asleep, bleeding from a head wound, he was a thief and a sinner. A gutter rat with no future. But when he woke up, he was God’s chosen, a messenger sent to pick up the fiery torch dropped by the vanished shepherd boy Stephen, and lead the pueri – the children -  onward to Jerusalem.

 

When Nick woke up, he told everyone about his dream. Anyone who would listen. With blood in his hair and tears in his eyes he told them that an angel had visited him in his sleep. That it had shown him how the Children’s Crusade was going to reach Jerusalem. Just as Moses had parted the Red Sea 2000 years earlier, Nicolas would part the Mediterranean Sea, and then the Children would simply walk down the corridor of dry land, all the way to the Holy City.

 

These days, when people like Nick try to tell us about their dreams, we shake our heads and say, ‘sorry I don’t have any change.” But in the early 13th century, in a social environment charged with religious belief, a teenage boy’s dream about an angel on a beach could have as much credibility as a missive from the Pope himself.

 

And so, at the city of Cologne, Nicolas the nobody soon found himself turned into a somebody. He is Stephen’s heir, they said! God has chosen him to lead the Crusade and guide us to the Holy Land. For the children and their movement, Nick brought something new to the table, something they did not have before: an actual plan. During the French phase of the movement, they knew the ‘where’, ‘when’ and ‘why’, but not the ‘how’. Would they take ships to the Holy Land, or march through the Balkans and go by way of Constantinople? But now, the road ahead of them was clear. God would perform miracles to help them, and he would perform them through Nicolas.

 

There were some, statistically, who must have called him a fraud or a faker. And maybe he was faking it. Just another trick pulled by a seasoned con-man in search of the next meal. Or maybe he got knocked a little too hard on the head during his scuffle with the bullies. But whether Nick’s revelation was genuine or not is beside the point. People believed it was real. Then as now, wherever there are people saying they saw God in a dream, on the road, or on a piece of burnt toast, there are people who will say “please - tell me more”.

 

And so, in the wake of his revelation, Nick was not only embraced by the pilgrims of the Children’s Crusade, they lifted him up into a position of leadership. A staff was made for him, a hunk of cheap iron was heated and hammered into the shape of a tau symbol, just like in his dream. According to Gary Dickson:

 

“Just as Stephen obtained his letters to King Philip, Nicholas somehow received his charismatic credential, his emblem. After leaving Cologne, Nicholas ceased to be a face in the crowd. Instead, he became its charismatic leader.”

 

Winding south along the Rhine River, thousands of pilgrims – little children and striding teenagers and hobbling old people – made their way through the roads and forests of Germany. When confused onlookers or concerned clergymen asked where they were going, the unarmed crusaders smiled and waved their little red crosses.

 

“To the sea!” they said. “To Jerusalem!”

 

“We can almost hear the mocking voices,” writes Gary Dickson, “Well, tell us how you’re going to do it!” The answer of the pueri was short and to the point: “We will cross the sea dry-shod, just as the people of Israel did in their flight out of Egypt.”

 

As historian Antony Bridge elaborates:

“The seas would dry up before them, as they had when Moses had led the children of Israel out of the land of Egypt; and God would deliver Jerusalem into their hands, for had not Christ said that unless people became as little children, they could by no means enter into the kingdom of heaven? Plainly therefore it was only to children that the gates of the heavenly city would be opened. Let them all trust in God and follow him (Nicolas), and he would lead them to victory in the power of the Holy Spirit.”

Walking at the head of his new flock, leading them south towards Italy and the Mediterranean Sea, 14/15-year-old Nicolas of Cologne carried his new staff, topped with an iron tau (a Greek cross). The symbolism of that ornament would not have been lost on the clergy that watched this procession trudge through the summer heat. As Dickson continues:

There is a remarkable reason why the tau spoke directly to Nicholas of Cologne and to the pueri. Christian scriptural commentators interpreted the tau cross as the symbol of the Exodus of the Children of Israel from Egypt. It was the sign of the lamb’s blood which the Israelites smeared on the door-posts of their houses in Egypt to ward off the angel of death (Exodus 12:7, 22). For the Rhenish pueri, that, too, would be their sign. As the climactic moment approached when they would re-enact the drama of the ancient Israelites by stepping into the water to cross the sea dry-shod, the tau would be there to keep them from harm. Protected by the tau, these new Children of Israel were prepared for their own Exodus. Leading them was their new Moses, Nicholas of Cologne.’

As July became August, and the summer of 1212 marched on, so did the children.

 

They passed towns and cities and monasteries. They crossed bridges and rivers and streams. In some villages they were showered with gifts; in others, they were pelted with stones. But through the wind, the rain and the heat, they kept on marching south. They passed through Trier, Lorraine, Bergundy and Bern – through the patchwork principalities of the Holy Roman Empire - and at every stop, there were literate men – monks and friars - scribbling furiously about this strange phenomenon. A People’s Crusade was not without precedent, of course. But the overwhelming proportion of young people in its ranks was new. According to Dickson:

 

“The youthfulness of the pueri partially accounts for the astonishment of the chroniclers. Seniors in medieval society were supposed to govern juniors. Leadership by the young was a disturbing reversal of the natural order of things, as was their departure in the teeth of parental opposition.”

 

The last sentence of that passage raises a very interesting question, one that’s probably been rattling around in your head since the start of this series. It’s certainly been rattling around in mine:

 

Where are the parents in all of this?

 

Now granted, people in the Middle Ages were very, very different from us, with a somewhat alien worldview and unique set of social norms – but they were still people. They still loved their kids. Compared to the 21stcentury, child mortality was extremely high during this period, and kids that managed to survive those first few years and grow into adolescence would’ve been seen by many parents as a tremendous gift, a miracle against the odds. As historian Hugh Cunningham writes in his book on medieval childhood:

 

“At least one out of every four babies born would fail to live to their first birthday If you survived your first hours, days, weeks and months of life, your prospects improved, but perhaps as many as a half of all children born would fail to reach the age of ten.”

 

In short, living children were precious things to their parents. Not only for the obvious sentimental value, but their ability to help around the house or work the farm or tend the shop. They were investments, both financial and emotional. So, why would so many parents allow so many kids to leave home and follow a strange, delusional boy a on a suicide mission to the Middle East? Well, the answer in many cases was that they didn’t. Some of the medieval sources make reference to parents literally locking their kids in the house when the Children’s Crusade came through town, hoping to limit their contact with Nicolas’s charismatic preaching.

 

In the same way that American parents in the 1950s told their kids to stay away from rock ‘n roll music and go to church, peasant families in Germany told their kids to stay away from that boy Nicolas and his army of fanatical hooligans.

 

And yet, it did not work.

 

Like Beatlemania sending shivers up the spines of teenage girls in the 1960s, Nicolas-Mania swept the German and Swiss country sides. He talks to God, they said! He performs miracles, they swooned. He will part the sea, convert the Saracens and reclaim Jerusalem! If there had been a medieval version of Tiger Beat or Teen People magazine, Nick’s face would’ve been plastered on the front of it, with a lopsided grin and his trademark tau staff. A teen idol for the Middle Ages.

 

Some parents resisted it, of course. Many more encouraged it. But most just made peace with it.

 

In the year 1861, about 650 years after the Children’s Crusade took place, a British oil painter named Joanna Boyce Wells completed a very famous composition, in which she imagined a moment between a medieval mother and her two children before they left home to join Nicolas’ crusade.

 

When you look at the painting, the first thing you’ll notice is a vivid splash of red. We see a young mother in a simple red dress and a white head-veil kneeling in the street. Her arms are wrapped tightly around a little girl, who looks to be around 6 years old. We can’t see the little girl’s face – she has her head buried in her Mom’s chest, but the body language is clearly one of ‘goodbye’. Standing next to the mother, an older boy, maybe 11 years old, is trying his best to look brave. He wears a long tunic with a bright red crusader cross freshly painted on the front. Despite his placid expression, the artist has put a subtle dash of unease into the boy’s features, a nervous crease in the eyebrows. For comfort, he holds his mother’s hand tight. As for Mom, her expression is one of acceptance. With eyes closed, she hugs her children one last time, before they go off to serve God.

 

This painting by Joanna Wells, which she titled “The Departure”, is fascinating because it is a case of someone from the distant past imagining people from the distant-er past. Someone from 150 years ago, imagining people from 800 years ago. And yet the feeling she has rendered into oil and canvas, the emotions she is capturing, are as eternal to the human experience as breathing. A mother saying goodbye to her children, understanding that she may never see them again.

 

If you’re curious to get a look at this painting, you already have. It’s the thumbnail artwork for this series. It took four years for Ms. Wells to complete her painting, which she did in 1861 before dying, ironically, in childbirth. But the very first brush strokes of “The Departure” were painted in a little town in Italy. Which is fitting, because Italy is exactly where our teenage protagonist and his 30,000 friends are headed.

 

By mid-August, Nicolas and his followers had reached Switzerland, 250 miles south of Cologne. Thus far, the terrain of their journey had been relatively easy – rolling farmland and temperate forests. But now, a new obstacle rose up before them – more daunting than any raging river or rickety bridge:

 

That massive spine of craggy, snow-covered mountains: the Swiss Alps.

Home to mountain goats, ski chalets and Julie Andrews musicals.

 

Now, on a personal note - I actually traveled through the Swiss Alps once. I was on a very nice train with big comfortable seats and floor-to-ceiling windows that made it easy to look out and take pictures for Instagram. On that train, we went very high and very deep into the mountains, and I can say without hesitation that it was one of the most beautiful places I’ve ever visited. But not once during that 4-hour train ride, did I ever think: you know, this would be really nice place to walk through on foot without food, shelter or cold-weather clothing.

 

And yet, that is exactly what Nicolas of Cologne and his followers did in 1212.

 

To reach Italy, their next stop on the road to Jerusalem, the children would have to travel over one of the largest and most treacherous mountain ranges in the world. They couldn’t go around it, they couldn’t go under it, and they certainly couldn’t take a ski lift. The only way forward was “through.”

 

As he led his followers up the mountain passes, and watched his breath turn to fog, Nicolas of Cologne would no doubt have been apprehensive. But when he got scared or anxious or uncertain, he clutched his tau staff a little tighter and thought about his dream. The power of the tau would protect them in the mountains, just as the lamb’s blood smeared on the doors in Egypt had protected the Israelites from the angel of death.

 

And so, Nicolas waved his flock forward and journeyed deeper into the mountains.

 

 

==== MUSIC BREAK =====  (18 pages in / 14 left)

 

It’s August 25th, 1212 AD.

 

We’re in Genoa, a bustling port city on the northwest coast of Italy.

 

Genoa – that’s G-E-N-O-A – is the kind of city where people are always coming and going. For every person stepping off their ship and onto the docks, someone else is hopping back onto their ship after a wild weekend, laden with new souvenirs, new trade goods, and possibly a new venereal disease.

 

Rising above the sparkling blue waves of the Mediterranean, Genoa is a postcard paradise, with Romanesque stone towers, colorful guild halls and a moon-shaped harbor packed with sleek merchant vessels. And although Genoa is very pretty, it is also very powerful.

 

The Republic of Genoa – as it is called - is a city that is so rich, so formidable, so utterly indispensable to the currents of Mediterranean trade, that it qualifies as economic engine unto itself. Other major cities, like London or Paris or Prague draw their power and tax revenue from large feudal territories that stretch for hundreds of miles. Genoa, on the other hand, is not a sprawling kingdom with one contiguous land mass. It is a city-state. Like Sparta and Athens of old, or its great rival, Pisa, Genoa’s power is concentrated like a bouillon cube into an area 1/7th the size of Central Park. And although you can walk from one side of Genoa to the other in a day, entire empires rise and fall based on the deals that are made here.

 

The reason Genoa has become so rich and powerful, is through trade. Positioned in the northwest armpit of Italy, ships come from all over the Mediterranean to buy, sell, barter and negotiate. Silks from Byzantium, slaves from Russia, olive oil from Spain and wine from France. If you want to buy it, Genoa sells it.

 

No doubt, the merchants and traders of Genoa have a nose for financial opportunity, which is why for the past hundred years or so, they have been heavily involved in the Crusades. Not fighting, of course. Nothing so dramatic as that. Genoa’s primary value to Christendom’s eternal struggle against Islam lies in transport and supply. These great clinking, clattering armies of knights and men and horses can’t just close their eyes and teleport to the Holy Land; they need naval transport. And for a large sack of gold, the sea dogs of Genoa are more than happy to get them there.

 

During the First, Second and Third Crusades, Genoa played a major role in transporting the crusader kings and their men to far-flung shores. In that time, they’ve all sorts of holy warriors march through their streets. Knights Templar carrying red cross shields. Hospitallers in their dusty blue surcoats. Frankish mercenaries and English archers. Crossbowmen from Prague and mercenaries from Milan.

 

But after 100 years of ferrying Crusaders, the Genoese have never seen the type of army that is marching though their streets today, on August 25th, 1212 AD.

 

They have red crosses on their tunics. Some of the older ones even have crosses tattooed on their skin. But they have no armor, no weapons, no horses, no flag. Most of them look like a steady sea-breeze might knock them to the cobbles.

 

The Children’s Crusade – what’s left of it, anyway - has arrived in Genoa. Six weeks after leaving city of Cologne, they have arrived at the sea. Staring out from their shop windows and food stalls, the merchants of Genoa cannot help but feel a stab of pity for pathetic procession stumbling through their streets. A rabble of peasants, serfs, shepherds - most of them children or adolescents - drag themselves like zombies through Genoa, and crowds of shoppers part like a human ocean to get out of their way.

 

These kids look like death, they think. And they don’t smell much better. They are scattered and tattered and emaciated, so skinny you can count their ribs. They look like they haven’t eaten or  seen a warm hearth in weeks. And that’s because they haven’t. At the head of this sad little column, hobbling on his tau staff like a crutch, is Nicolas of Cologne. After weeks on the road, the Children’s Crusade has finally reached the sea, but at a terrible cost. Before they entered the mountains, their numbers were estimated to be 20-30,000. But upon reaching Genua, there are only 7,000 of them left.

 

What happened to you, the adults ask? Where did you come from? Clutching his Tau staff, Nicolas looks back over his shoulder in the direction of the mountains, and feels a chill that even the warm ocean breeze cannot soothe.

 

INTO THE MOUNTAINS

 

A few weeks earlier, when the Children began their ascent into the alpine passes of Switzerland, they’d been singing and praying and chanting with starry-eyed enthusiasm. Almost there, they said to each other. A quick trip over the mountains, and then we’ll be at the sea. Sure, there might be a little cold, some discomfort, a few frostbitten noses – but through the power of the tau, and Nicolas of Cologne, the Lord will protect us from harm.

 

Unfortunately for the children, the mountains did not seem to fall within God’s jurisdiction. It’s often said by the devout that ‘hell is the absence of God” and for the children in the Alps, that was most certainly true.  

 

When the great Carthaginian commander Hannibal Barca famously crossed the Alps to invade Roman Italy in 218 B.C., he did so with one of the finest, most well-equipped armies in antiquity. 50,000 infantry, 10,000 cavalry and dozens of war elephants – fully equipped with supplies, provisions and state-of-the-art weaponry. And yet, for all their training and preparation, the mountains proved deadlier than any Roman legion ever could. When Hannibal and his army staggered out of the alpine passes two weeks later, their numbers had been depleted by more than fifty percent. Most of those mighty war elephants dropped dead in the snow, stretching back along their route like frozen mile-markers.  

 

Nicolas of Cologne and his followers were probably not well versed on the campaign tactics of long dead Carthaginian generals, but if they had been, they probably would’ve chosen a different route. They would’ve known that even a well-trained, fully-equipped army of professional soldiers was no match for the Alps. And 1400 years later, when the Children’s Crusade entered those mountains without supplies, food, shelter or cold weather gear – they were all but doomed from the start.

 

The summer of 1212 was an especially hot one, and some medieval chroniclers even comment on how remarkable it was that the Children’s Crusade were traveling in those sweltering conditions. “The heat was extremely great in the first 15 days of July,” wrote a monk named Renier. But all that was changed when Nicolas and his followers trekked into the mountains. Up at those altitudes, the snow does not melt, not even in summer, and at night the temperatures can plummet to well below freezing.

 

For weeks, the pilgrims had been relying on the kindness of strangers for a steady supply of food, but in the Alps, there were no towns or villages to seek shelter in. Nothing to eat but ice and snow and weeds. There was no dry wood to build a fire, and no hunting gear to catch the occasional rabbit that scurried through the snow.

 

Nicolas was confident that God would protect their souls, but He would not protect their bodies from hypothermia or their feet from frostbite. If the Almighty watching the Children’s Crusade from heavenly throne in the summer of 1212, he kept silent as the pilgrims collapsed into the snow, starved to death in cold ravines, or were buried alive in sudden avalanches or rockslides.

The fog was so thick, that some children got separated from the main group and wandered through the mountains, lost, alone and freezing to death. By the third week in August, more than ten thousand little bodies were lying face down and frozen in the snow.

 

But not all the Children died. The older ones, the stronger ones, made it through the mountains, and when they saw the foothills of Northern Italy, the survivors fell to their knees and praised God for his mercy. Despite their ordeal, not all was lost. They were only a few days from the ocean, they could practically smell the sea; and most importantly, the boy who would part it was still with them.  The Crusade’s venerated leader, Nicolas of Cologne, had survived the lethal conditions in the mountains. He might be 15 pounds lighter and on the verge of losing a few toes, but he still had his faith, his dream and his tau staff. To his 7,000 surviving followers, it was just more proof of his divinity.

 

“We are delivered!” they sang through chattering teeth and sore throats. God has tested us severely, many of our friends are dead, but… were the Israelites not tested? Were Abraham and Isaac not tested? Was Jesus himself not tested in the desert? Well, we have emerged from a cold desert of our own, and Nicolas has seen us through! Nicolas of Cologne and the protection of his tau staff.

 

And what did Nicolas the Protector think of all this? Did he feel guilty at the death of so many of his followers? Did he feel unsure of himself, doubtful of his abilities? OR did he feel emboldened by his own survival, more certain than ever that he was chosen by God. Well, like most details of this story, we will never know for sure. But what we do know this: On August 25th, 1212 AD, the 7,000 survivors of the Children’s Crusade reached the port of Genua and Mediterranean Sea.

 

Since they set out from Cologne many weeks earlier, the children had been constantly asking “are we there yet?”, “are we there yet?”, “when will we reach the sea?”

 

Well, now it stretched out before them, wide and blue and glittering in the Italian sun. When they arrived in Genoa, the bustling port offered all kinds of new sights and sounds for the French and German pilgrims. They heard merchants chattering in strange languages. They saw architectural styles that made the gothic towers back home look dreary in comparison. They saw the Genoese eating bizarre coast foods like fresh crab, oysters and octopus. But there was no time to dally in the delights of Genoa. They were not here to be tourists. They were here for a higher purpose. They were here to witness a miracle.

 

The beaches of Genoa were nothing like the one In Nicolas’ dream. In the dream, the beach had been perfectly flat and placid, untouched by the footfalls of man or beast. The beaches of Genoa, on the other hand, were hot, noisy and pungent, with crabbers hauling up nets and heaps of old seaweed decomposing in the heat. But no one ever said that miracles require a grand venue. According to church lore, the Apostles had healed cripples in backwater villages and called up earthquakes in the wilderness.

 

And now Nicolas, the 14/15-year-old boy from Cologne, would perform his very own miracle. He would part the sea and lead them across the sand to Jerusalem.

 

As musicians and stage performers know (all too well), there is no deeper silence than the silence of a large group of people watching you and waiting for you to do something impressive. Standing on the shore at Genua, surrounded by a massive crowd of half-starved pilgrims, Nicolas felt the expectation of the moment bearing down on him like a boulder. He felt the wet sand between his toes, and the hot sun on his forehead, and he heard the older teenagers hushing the little kids beside them.

 

“Miracle” is an interesting word. It comes from the Latin word miraculum, which means “object of wonder.” It’s a word that has lost some of its power over the centuries. These days, A colleague who sends you a PowerPoint ahead of schedule is a “miracle worker”. Beating the traffic and making it home before dinner is a ‘minor miracle’. And a jar of mass-produced mayonnaise is Miracle Whip.

 

But in 1212 AD, “miracle” was not a word just casually thrown around. It meant making the impossible possible. It meant bending the laws of nature to the will of Heaven. And as the crowd of pilgrims watch Nicolas of Cologne dip his tau staff into the waves, they are convinced that they will be witnesses to the greatest miracle of the Age.

 

Trying his best to ignore the heat, the smell of seaweed, and the smothering hush of his followers, Nicolas closes his eyes.

 

He knows that something is supposed to happen. He doesn’t know how it’s going to happen or when it’s going to happen, only that it will happen. But as Nick pushes the staff deeper into the sand, waiting for the waves to part, a little panic starts to rise in his chest. In the dream, the angel, that terrible mass of flame and eyes, had said “to the sea.” It didn’t specify which sea. It just said “the sea”. Maybe this was the wrong sea. Maybe this was the wrong place. Maybe all those people who died in the Alps were signs from God trying to tell him he was going the wrong way?

 

Leaning on the staff with all his strength, pushing it deeper into the sand, Nicolas squeezes his eyes tight and starts praying. If you’re going to do something, now would be the time. Otherwise, why would you bring me here? Why would you bring all of us here? Why would you show me what you showed me, just to abandon us? Why aren’t you helping? Where the hell are you?

 

And then, the staff snaps.

 

It is an awful, abrupt cracking sound. The crowd gasps as Nick falls stumbles into the surf, and 7,000 hearts drop with him. People rush forward to help him to his feet, but the effect of what has happened is already worming its way through the crowd like a contagion.

 

The sea has not parted. It has not even rippled. There’s no angel, no corridor, no holy city gleaming in the distance. Just the soft lapping waves, and the cruel laughter of fishermen. Nick blinks the saltwater out of his eyes and watches the pieces of his tau staff bob in the surf like a broken toy.

 

In that horrifying, humiliating moment, Nick comprehends, but he does not understand. He has failed to part the sea. He has failed to do the one thing he’s been promising to do for the last six weeks and 400 miles. Which can mean there are only two possibilities. He has either misinterpreted the dream and led his flock to the wrong beach, or he is the target of the greatest practical joke in the history of the cosmos.

 

But Nick is a not a brittle person. You don’t spend years surviving on the mean streets of Cologne without learning the finer points of improvisation. When a mark catches you in the act, or a guard chases you down an alley, or a sack of coins turns out to be a sack of turnips, you come up with a Plan B. And you do it fast. And before the seawater can turn to salt crystals on his skin, Nick has a new plan. A new interpretation. A new idea.

 

God is testing us again, he shouts to his confused and disappointed followers. I understand now. I see now that we are not meant to literally part the sea, but cross it! On great wooden ships! The way mortal men should. And God, in his wisdom, has guided us to a place absolutely teeming with ships. Look around you, look out on the waves. This harbor is full of god-fearing sailors that will be moved by the sincerity of our cause, and they will take us to the Holy Land. Our journey isn’t over, my friends, it’s only beginning!

 

For some people in the crowd, Nick’s words ring true. His spectacular failure to part the sea has dimmed but not extinguished the fire of their belief. There is a certain percentage of this crowd that will follow him anywhere. But for most of the pilgrims, Nick has just revealed himself to be a fraud. Yet another false prophet. Yet another disappointment. We came all this way, they said. We died for you! We watched our friends die! You had ONE job!

 

If Nicolas and his Crusade were truly favored by God, something would have happened here. The sky would have darkened, thunder and lightning would’ve cracked and flashed. The sea would’ve split open like a fissure and all the death, discomfort and misery they’d endured since Germany would’ve been worth it.

 

But that didn’t happen. This kid wasn’t special. He was just a kid. Nicolas the Nobody.

> 

And so, the crowd begins to melt away. The 7,000 pilgrims dissolve and disperse, leaving behind only a small cadre of hardcore followers. As Gary Dickson writes:

 

For a good number of the pueri, having reached the sea at long last, a major setback like this was enough to put an end to their crusading dreams. The picture was not altogether bleak, however. For the “many” ex-crusaders who chose to stay on in Genoa there was a good chance of ready employment.

 

Italy transformed them. When the pueri crossed the Alps, they were still pilgrims and crusaders. Then, step by step, their collective identity as religious vagrants began to melt away. Their metamorphosis, almost imperceptible at first, resulted in a change of status. Crusaders no longer, they were gradually becoming immigrants. In Ogerio Pane’s (a contemporary chronicler’s) words: “many men, women, boys and girls of that number [the 7,000-plus] remained in Genoa.” A mixture of frustrated expectations and new opportunities accounted for what happened.”

 

But for Nick and his hardcore followers, the story was not over. The sea had not parted, and there was no realistic possibility of contracting ships to take them to the Holy Land, not unless the sailors accepted prayers as payment. But there was someone who might help them. Someone who might see the truth of their mission. 

 

In the shadow of his failure, Nick realizes there’s only one thing left to do.

They have to go to Rome. They have to see the Pope.

 

 

==== MUSIC BREAK ===== (24 pages / 7 left)

 

It’s November 11th, 1215 A.D.

Roughly three years after Nicolas of Cologne failed to part the sea at Genoa.  

 

We’re in the city of Rome – birthplace/wellspring of crusades, seat of the Papacy, and heart of Latin Christendom itself.

 

For much of its history, Rome was a pagan city. At the height of the Roman Empire, the Eternal City was saturated/filled with temples and shrines and statues, each dedicated to a member of that divine and dysfunctional pantheon. By the glow of moonlight, priests and priestesses lit incense for Minerva, offered jars of wine to Neptune, and sacrificed snow-white bulls to Jupiter.

 

But then, sometime during the reign of Emperor Tiberius, legionaries in Palestine executed a 33-year-old Jewish activist on a hill outside of Jerusalem. As they hammered iron nails into the man’s wrists and feet, and slipped a spear between his ribs for good measure, none of the overworked legionaries could’ve imagined that 1000 years later, all those marble statues in Rome would be supplanted by the image of their victim’s last moments.

 

In 1215 A.D., the image of the crucifix – Jesus nailed to his cross - is everywhere in Rome. “It was omnipresent,“ writes Gary Dickson, “—conspicuous in the countryside; in the marketplace; on mountain tops; in cemeteries; at the boundaries of landed properties; at commemorative sites; places of sanctuary; on churches; and, of course, at crossroads.”

 

Yes, the priests have changed – and so have the sacrifices – but Rome is still a very religious city.

 

Reminders of the old Roman Empire remain, of course. The famous Flavian Amphitheatre – or the Colosseum - looms over the city, silent as a graveyard. The ruins of the Circus Maximus, where charioteers raced and smashed into each other, still sit near the Tiber River. And for students of the Justinian era, the Aurelian walls still stand, where the celebrated general Belisarius fought off an assault by an Ostrogothic army.

 

But in 1215, all that stuff is ancient history. Useless piles of decadent old stone. The real focus of the city, the real center of attention in Rome, is a place called the Palazzo del Laterno – or the Lateran Palace, so named because it sits on top of Lateran Hill. In a city filled with palaces and villas, estates, mansions and manors…this one is by far the most important. And that’s because the Lateran Palace is the personal residence and workplace of the Holy Father, Pope Innocent III.

 

And on this chilly November day in 1215, Innocent is very, very stressed out.

 

As a rule, Popes do not get stressed out. Endowed with God-given calm, they approach every situation with unflappable wisdom and grace. Not one Papal portrait in the history of the Church shows a pontiff biting his nails or wiping his brow. But in reality, Popes are just men. And on the most important day of their lives, at the make-or-break culmination of their career, men get stressed out.

 

When he woke up this morning, Lothar’s heart was hammering like a drum. Even after putting on the robe and sash and papal vestments that transform him daily into Innocent III, he is still plagued by the imps and demons of anxiety. After years of planning, months of organizing, and weeks of coordinating, the Fourth Lateran Council is about to begin.

 

The Roman Catholic Church, like all powerful institutions, has rules. In the same way that lawyers have strict procedures for the application of the law, the Clergy has strict procedures for the application of the faith. As the borders of Christendom expanded over the centuries, and the people within those borders became more and more diverse, a certain degree of standardization was required. We may speak different languages and eat different food and swear allegiance to different kings, but certain common denominators need to be established. Just as McDonald’s french fries taste the exact same in Texas or Tokyo, a Catholic mass needed to be recognizable in every church across Europe.

 

And to that end, once a generation or so, the Medieval Catholic Church calls all of its representatives together for a sort of convention in Rome – an ecclesiastical Comic-Con called a Lateran Council, which takes place at the Pope’s Lateran Palace. By the early 13th century, there have been three of these Lateran councils. One in 1123, one in 1139, and one in 1179. And this latest one, called by his Holiness Pope Innocent, will be the Fourth.

 

For the first time in 36 years, 404 bishops, 71 cardinals, 800 abbots, 23 Orthodox prelates (preh-lut) will gather in Rome to hammer out the latest controversies of the Catholic faith, everything from matrimonial rites and confessional rituals to the exact definition of ‘heresy’.

 

And not only will the clergy be in attendance, but secular political leaders as well. In a sharp break from tradition, Pope Innocent has chosen to include layman – or non-clergymen - at his Council. Representatives from all the great kingdoms, duchies and fiefdoms in Europe are coming. There will be dukes from Spain, barons from Germany, princes from Hungary. It was, essentially, a summit of the most influential people in Latin Christendom. As historian F. Donald Logan observes: “The Fourth Lateran Council was the most important general council of the church in the Middle Ages.”

 

Needless to say, as he glides down the crowded hallways of the Palazzo de Laterno, draped in his trademark red and white, Pope Innocent III has a lot on his mind. A council of this size and importance only takes place once in a generation, much less once in a single Papacy, so Innocent is under a lot of pressure to perform. It is not overly dramatic to say that his entire legacy rests on the outcome of this Council.

 

There were, of course, so many issues to resolve, so many theological knots to untangle. From the question of whether clergymen can gamble or hunt, to defining the exact point at which bread and wine literally become the body and blood of Christ – or transubstantiation - there were all sorts of things to discuss. But the main reason the Council is so important to Pope Innocent, is because it is here that he intends to call the next Crusade. The Fifth – and hopefully final – Crusade. Unlike the disastrous Fourth crusade of 1204, this next military expedition needed to be a successful and lasting one.

> 

And as he prepares for the Council, prowling his palazzo with the nervous energy of a wedding planner, Pope Innocent catches sight of a small troupe of choirboys filing down the halls like little ducklings. And when he sees them, Innocent’s mind is suddenly transported back to a very strange day he had three years earlier. He is reminded of a very different group of boys with a very different purpose.

 

It had been a chilly day in September of 1212 AD, and like all days in the Pope’s career, it began with morning prayers, followed by a modest breakfast, a trip to the privy and a mountain of paperwork. But then, while Innocent was ruminating on heretics in France and succession crises in Germany, a servant scuttled up to his desk and delivered a piece of unexpected news.

 

The pueri are here, your Holiness.

The children have arrived in Rome.

 

Pope Innocent received this news like a homeowner being told he has termites. They are here, there are hundreds of them, and they are not going away easily.

 

Truthfully, Innocent had been dreading this possibility for almost six months, ever since he first heard the troubling reports about a French shepherd boy with holy letters. Week by week, he had followed it all. The drama at St. Denis, the journey to Cologne, the rise of this boy Nicolas with the Tau cross who promised to part the sea. It would’ve been easy to dismiss the so-called Children’s Crusade as a flash in the pan – a regional curiosity - but this Pope was nothing if not thorough. “Innocent,” writes M.J. Trow, “was watching events carefully.”

 

Shooing the servant away with the flick of his wrist, the Pope sat back in his chair, steepled his fingers and pondered about how to respond to this unwelcome arrival.

 

The good news, of course, was that by now, the Children’s Crusade had dwindled to a fraction of its former size. The original 30,000 that set out from the hinterlands of France and Germany had been decimated by the perils of the road, the snows in the Alps, and the demoralizing failure at Genoa. According to Innocent’s informers, there couldn’t be more that 1500 of them now. Barely enough to fill the pews of a small cathedral.

 

And yet, the Children staggered on, bound for Rome itself. As Dickson writes:

 

“Leaving Genoa behind them, a sizable number of young and not-so-young crusaders would have taken the Roman road southwards. Perhaps they were still determined to wheedle or beg their way across the Mediterranean to the Holy Land. Perhaps Nicholas of Cologne still marched at the head of their procession. That possibility exists because for some true believers, charisma, like prophecy, cannot be allowed to fail. Too much psychological capital has been invested in it.”

 

But what did they want?, mused Innocent. By coming to Rome, Nicolas and his followers were clearly hoping for some sort of Papal audience, but to what end?

 

Well, in the Pope’s mind, there were only two possibilities. Either the Children wanted his support, to breathe new life into their dwindling Crusade…or, they wanted him to release them from it. As Dickson writes:

 

“Their motive may have been obtaining dispensation from their crusade vows. These were still binding, regardless of the fact their crusade was unauthorized.”

 

After the reality check at Genoa, Nicolas and his followers might have come to the bitter realization that they were not going to make it to Jerusalem. They had no ships, no money and no miracles. But that didn’t mean they could just turn around, go home, and act like nothing had ever happened. By taking the Cross, they had made a sacred vow, a promise to God that could not be broken on pain of excommunication or even eternal damnation. Before they could go home, before they could go back to their old lives, the Church would need to officially release them from those vows.

 

So, Pope Innocent smiled, after all that talk of miracles and parting the sea, after their defiance of King Phillip and flouting of Church tradition, these naughty children come crawling to Rome, begging to be released from spiritual time-out.

 

Suddenly, a voice interrupted his thoughts. A question from his servant. Shall I have their leader brought to you, Your Holiness? Would you like to speak with this… “Nicolas of Cologne”?

 

What a stupid question, Innocent thought, rolling his eyes to the vaulted ceiling. He could not lower himself in that way. Jesus may have entertained beggars and thieves, but as a rule, Popes do not meet with peasants. Set that precedent, and the Palazzo de Laterno would be crawling with flea-bitten petitioners from all over Christendom. But it was interesting, just as a thought experiment, to wonder “what if?”

 

What if, Innocent wondered, in some rare act of Papal benevolence, I *did* choose to meet with these wayward children? What would they say? What would I say to them?

 

Ministry had never been Innocent’s strong suit. He grew up studying canon law, not the lesser arts of tending to the flock. Innocent knew every filament of every strand of Church doctrine; he knew how to hijack imperial successions and excommunicate the most powerful men in Europe, but the subtleties of personal faith / the human soul were more of a mystery to him.

 

And if the Pope was being truly, brutally honest with himself, the Children’s Crusade had plucked a string of insecurity somewhere within him. It took every ounce of his political skill and considerable influence to motivate the kings and princes of Europe to do what he wanted. But these boys, Nicolas and Stephen, who had no power, no titles, no red robes or vestments – they were able to inspire thousands of people to chase an impossible dream.

 

With a twinge of self-doubt, Innocent had to wonder, could I ever move people the way Nicolas and Stephen have? If you took away the chains of office and the brigades of bishops; if you put me in a field with nothing but a staff, my voice, and a crowd of peasants… could Lothar, ever do what these boys have done? Would God talk to me, like He talked to them? Could I create an army of believers with nothing but my words?

 

Well, Innocent decided that was a question he did not want an answer to.

 

“No,” he snapped at his servant, straightening his robes. “I will not meet with them. Tell this boy and his followers that they are released from their “vows”. Tell them the best way for them to serve God is to go home, keep the peace, and do as they’re told. Any child among them, anyone younger than 14, is free to put down their burden. The very old and infirm too may consider themselves relieved. As for the rest, they are are adults, and adults must live with their choices. That’ll be all.”

 

The servant bowed low, turned on his heel, and removed himself from the Holy Father’s presence. A few hours later, he was delivering the Pope’s message – verbatim – to a stunned Nicolas of Cologne and a handful of loyal pilgrims. Without sentiment or ceremony, the gates of the palazzo del Laterno slammed shut in their faces, startling a flock of pigeons into the air.

 

And with the shutting of those gates, the Children’s Crusade was officially over.

 

AFTERMATH

 

Having sent the Children packing, Pope Innocent III turned his attention to bigger and better things, specifically plans for his landmark religious conference, the Fourth Lateran Council. And three years later, in November of 1215, he stood before the assembly and officially launched the Fifth Crusade. With a cheer and roar, the nobility of Europe raised their swords high and vowed – yet again – to retake the Holy Land.

 

But despite Innocent’s curt dismissal of the Children three years before, the statutes and finer points of canon law which animated the Fifth Crusade seem to bear faint traces of Nicolas and Stephen’s movement. Some historians have even suggested that The Children’s Crusade may have had a direct impact on in the way Crusades were launched going forward. As Dickson writes:

Indeed, it was only six months after the peregrinatio puerorum that Innocent III announced a new crusade to the Holy Land. Now, for the first time, all the faithful were encouraged to step forward and take the cross. This fundamental shift in papal recruitment policy bore the imprint of the pueri. No longer would crusading be the exclusive business of the chivalric classes and their men-at-arms. A new papal appreciation for the crusading aspirations of the Christian people had come into being. Virtually all the populus christianus were now offered the opportunity to take part in the great enterprise of Christendom, to take the vow and receive the crusade indulgence, even if they redeemed their vow immediately afterwards for a cash payment. Thanks to the pueri, Pope Innocent was aware of continuing, deep-rooted, populist crusading sentiment, and he was determined to mobilize it.

But that wasn’t all. There were more overt traces of the Children’s Crusade influence at the Lateran Council. Dickson continues:

 

In his celebrated opening sermon to the Fourth Lateran Council in Rome, Innocent III invoked the mystic power of the tau cross. To Innocent, the tau would be the distinctive badge of a new crusader-elect. Innocent had used the tau as a crusader symbol previously, but at the Fourth Lateran it was also emblematic of church reform. The symbol, one feels, has been refreshed and re-energized. It may even be that Innocent’s choice of the tau as his central sign of reformist and crusader chosenness reflects the memory and influence of Nicholas of Cologne’s charismatic attribute. 

 

The Papacy would never have acknowledged any such connection at the risk of vindicating Nicolas and his followers, but the calling of the Fifth Crusade seems to have been, at the very least, shaped by the Children.

 

However, if Innocent had hoped to see the driving obsession of his Papacy – a successful Crusade – come to fruition, the Almighty had other plans for the Vicar of Christ. As historian John Juluis Norwich writes:

 

“In July 1216 (less than a year after the Lateran Council) the pope left Rome for the North, hoping to settle the age-old quarrel between Genoa and Pisa so that the two great maritime republics could collaborate in the projected Crusade. Some years before, he had suffered a severe attack of malaria which had brought him to the edge of the grave; he had gotten no further than Perugia when the same disease struck again. A day or two later he was dead. He was fifty-five. The following night, the house in which he had died was broken into and his body stolen. It was found the next day, stripped naked and rapidly decomposing in the summer heat, and was hastily buried in the Cathedral of San Lorenzo. At some later date, we are told, the bones of one of the greatest—if not the greatest—of medieval popes were heedlessly thrown, together with those of Urban IV and Martin IV, into a box which was stored in a cupboard in the sacristy of the new cathedral. At the end of the nineteenth century Leo XIII ordered that they be brought back to the Lateran; and so they were finally returned to Rome, in the suitcase of a priest, by rail.”

 

No, Pope Innocent III did not live to see Jerusalem restored. In fact, he did not even live to see the start of the Crusade he had launched, which did not depart for the Holy Land until over a year after his death.  / (later: the fifth time was not the charm)

 

But what about Nicolas of Cologne and his fellow pilgrims? What happened to them? Well, in the years following the unceremonious termination of the Children’s Crusade at the gates of Rome, all sorts of rumors circulated and swirled. Around campfires from Norway to Naples, colorful storytellers imagined all sorts of fantastical fates for Nicolas and his flock.

 

>>> 

Some said that a remnant of the Children’s Crusade broke off from the main group at Genoa and made its way to the French port of Marseilles, where they did finally find ships willing to take them to the Holy Land. But the Mediterranean is a treacherous place, and circumstance did not smile on their voyage. As a medieval writer named Alberic of Trois-Fontaine explains:

 

They had filled seven large ships … and when they were two days out – at the island of St Peter [off Sardinia] at the rock called Recluse – a storm blew up and two ships were lost. All the children were drowned … the five remaining ships [sailed] to Bougie and Alexandria and there sold … to Saracen noblemen and merchants.’

 

Other chronicles imagined more dramatic and exotic epilogues. A Dominican priest named Vincent of Beauvais concocted a wild story wherein the children were deceived by two clerics, who promised to take them to the Holy Land, but in actuality sold them off to be trained as slaves and assassins for Muslim warlords.

 

Other chroniclers, such as the Abbot of Stade, simply embraced the mystery of it all, writing about 30 years after the event:

 

Even now it is unknown what happened to them. But many of them returned home, and when they were asked the reason for their journey, they said they did not know. Also around the same time naked women (nudae mulieres) ran through the towns and cities saying nothing.

 

But of all the stories and speculative yarns spun about the ultimate fate of Nicolas of Cologne, one of the most interesting, and plausible comes from an Austrian cleric in Admont Abbey. He claimed to have heard reports that after his rejection at the gates of Rome, Nicholas did not go home, nor was he tricked or sold into slavery. Instead, he and his hardcore followers journeyed southeast to the port of Brindisi, where they stayed for many years, presumably working and scratching a living on the shores of a sea they could not part. But then, in the summer of 1217, opportunity struck.

 

By that time, five years after the Children’s Crusade, Pope Innocent III’s latest official crusade was well underway. The Pope was in Heaven, as they say, but his call to arms was still alive and well in the angry eyes of thousands of crusader soldiers boarding ships for the holy land. And a main staging area for those ships was the port of Brindisi, where Nicolas of Cologne and his friends had settled after their own failed Crusade. By this time, they would’ve been older, wiser, bigger and stronger; and this was their chance to be real crusaders in a real crusade.  As Gary Dickson writes:

 

“There was now an official, papally-proclaimed crusade in progress, and Nicholas was a sworn crusader with a vow to keep. To fulfill his vow, Nicholas was intent upon serving in the papal army. […] Nicholas himself probably did not think of it as a new crusade. To him, it would have been the continuation, the prolongation—indeed, the final chapter—of his pilgrimage.”

 

We can almost imagine Nicholas of Cologne, no longer a skinny teenager but a strong and weathered 20-year-old man, strapping on whatever armor and weapons he could afford. A dented helmet, a rusty coat of hand-me-down chainmail, and a flimsy spear.

 

But history is not without a sense of irony, and for the first time in crusading history, the main target of the Fifth Crusade was not Jerusalem, but Egypt. The Crusader fleet sailed to the Nile delta, where it hoped to cripple Muslim military power at its source, the heart of the Ayyubid Sultanate. It was an admirable change in strategy, but sadly, fifth time was not the charm. The Nile ran red with the blood of Christian knights, and in 1221 AD, Pope Innocent’s posthumous project ended in catastrophic failure, just like all the rest. The sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth crusades followed similar trajectories, and by 1291, two centuries after the first expedition was launched, Christendom’s appetite for the reconquest of the Levant had been exhausted.

 

But in 1217, standing on the deck of a ship bound for the Holy Land, Nicolas of Cologne doesn’t know any of that.  All he knows that the abiding, all-consuming dream he has harbored since he was a 15-year-old boy is finally coming to fruition. He doesn’t know that he and his fellow crusaders are sailing towards yet another disaster. He doesn’t know that tens of thousands of people will die in yet another futile war. He doesn’t even know if his particular ship will make it to Egypt, or if it will, like so many others be swallowed up by the sea in a storm or a squall.

 

All he knows is that he’s not a child. Not anymore.

He is an adult. And adults, for better worse, make their own choices.

And for better or worse, adults make their own choices.

 

---- OUTRO -----

 

Well guys, with that, our short & sweet series on the Children’s Crusade is officially over.

 

But if you’ve made it this far, and you’re wondering what podcast to listen to next, I have a humble suggestion for you. 

American Criminal is a meticulously researched history podcast that takes listeners deep into the crimes that have defined America. They cover all kinds of crimes, from headline-grabbing murders like the assassination of Harvey Milk to the little-known stories that literally shaped laws, culture, and religion, like the master forger Mark Hofmann. Whatever the case, whoever the criminal, the folks at American Criminal are there to give you the full story in all its glory.

Each individual season spans three to five episodes that detail the crime itself, the life of the people behind it, and the historical context of that moment. They don’t just tell you about who was involved, we talk about the way society reacted, how the media covered the story, and how history has reevaluated the case in the years since.

If you’re looking for a place to start, check out their series on The Salt Lake City Bombings.
In 1985, a series of bombs exploded across Salt Lake City, claiming two lives and plunging the city into a state of panic. As the dust settled, it was clear that these blasts were linked, but investigators couldn’t work out how. But one thing was for certain, everything led back to the Mormon church.

So with all that said, thank you again for spending your valuable time with me, and I hope you have an awesome day.

This has been Conflicted. Thanks for listening.

 

---- END -----